Share

FIRSTonline Banner

Minimal State or Welfare State? What is the real divide between left and right today, and why does the center prevail?

The neoliberal model reveals its contradictions, from the protection of public services to progressive taxation. For the left, the challenge is to rebuild a credible project and rally the center ahead of the upcoming elections.

Minimal State or Welfare State? What is the real divide between left and right today, and why does the center prevail?

What is done from time to time by those who are elected implements the political project proposed to the voter. Today for the left democratic the project can only be the Social status, in contrast to the dominant ideology since the late 80s Minimum state of neoliberalism, which identified itself with the right (Reagan; Thatcher). We understand, it cannot be the welfare state of the past; it needs to be rethought; but, to simplify, the same philosophy of Keynesian memory has been revived. In Italy Ugo La Malfa; and the Catholic currents inspired by rerum novarum, still significant today.

The force in propagating neoliberal ideas was such that it involved the same Labor (Socialists, Democrats), to the point that the conflict has boiled down to who offers the best leadership; not to a conflict over social projects. The slogan has followed: you win in the centerIn this context, voters with low or fixed incomes, unable to find anyone to offer solutions to the accumulating practical problems, have often listened to the sirens of populism, which proposes miraculous solutions, not analytically explained, to instead pursue its own policies, disguised as popular: drastic tax cuts, because everyone will benefit; concentration of wealth, to encourage investment; freedom of operators, to promote innovation even at the risk of fraud.

Minimal state, because the market is not enough

In fact it Minimum state It's a fiction, bent to the interests of the corporations that appropriate it. First, to deregulate competition, conflicts of interest, and areas at risk of fraud; then, to appropriate convenient privatizations. In Italy, it's far from minimal. It interferes in the management of companies; it reappropriates enterprises that could well be left to the market; and by interfering, it alters the market's play according to the pressures of more or less friendly bodies. Again. In the apparent safeguard of the welfare state, e.g. Health, this is in fact suffocated: everyone thinks of himself – at his own costs – with insurance and private healthcare (the bodies that press). The own costs do not replace the common cost of the tax. Health private , private school cost the country (as a whole) more than the data management; public, with short-term results that are difficult for the patient to assess (it's not like bread, which I can quickly estimate if it's convenient for me to change bakers). These are sectors not exposed to competition; monopolistic positions are created.

The proposal of the minimal state is nationalistic because it is easier to take over the State. But we are part of the EU which gives us the possibility to interact in the world's structures; in not falling into the Divide and conquerFor this you need to start the federalism with the recognition of the Union's powers of common spending and therefore of tax revenue. The proposal for a minimal state lacks democratic sensitivity: it is argued that democracy exists in the private market (economic and social). In Italy, defense Democratic It may prove weak. The long tradition of a Communist Party advocating democratic centralism has accustomed people to the idea that those who govern (and control the police and military forces) are chosen by co-optation; the people don't want to be concerned and, in any case, don't understand. For Italy, I stick to the facts, while aware of the ideological differences within the current majority itself.

Welfare state, the challenge of alliances

The first problem for the social direction of the State is the formation of the balanceA drastic reorganization of the tax system, based on progressiveness, is essential. I intend to return to this topic after examining the proposals being prepared by political forces.

Here too, the national elections They're getting closer. Is the proposal for a social direction against the neoliberal minimal state possible and credible?

A portion, more consistent than the physiological one, does not exercise the vote; probably it does not feel differences that could attract it. populism The minimal state influences who votes, but I don't believe it's the dominant part of the vote. Those who vote are already partially directed. Those who aren't may still find themselves entangled in the current system; especially in the fiscal sphere, in the advantages for financial income, in the lack of progressivity, in the loopholes that open up to evasion, in the repeated amnesties and settlements. Some may be tempted to cast their vote for a more sound administration and to eliminate abnormally favorable situations (e.g., inheritance); but they fear upheavals in their personal positions. With these interests, the direction of the welfare state must currently make compromises: with patience, an agreement can be found. the left must unite the center: center-left. But it should still be emphasized (and made clear to voters) that there is a political faction that supports the welfare state; that will support it within the limits of the legislative agreement; that aims to unite for greater power. How things unfold will tell.

comments