Green homes are a continuing battle between Italy and the EU. The object of contention is the EU directive which stipulates: 1) for residential buildings, member states must adopt measures that guarantee an average reduction in primary energy consumption of at least 16% by 2030 and at least 20-22% by 2035. 2) on the non-residential front, 16% of the worst-performing properties will have to be renovated by 2030, a percentage that will rise to 26% by 2033, introducing minimum energy performance requirements. By 2040, all traditional fossil-fuel boilers will have to be phased out.
Already at the time of the directive's approval, Italy – together with Hungary – had opposed the reform of the building regulations, considering it a counterproductive choice. Italy and Hungary were the only two member states opposed., still required to comply, like everyone else. Now Italy is back in the fray, asking for "greater flexibility" in adapting our homes to EU obligations regarding energy efficiency and zero emissions, but has received a resounding "no."
The League, one of the governing parties, is leading the charge: a question signed by three MEPs—Anna Maria Cisint, Aldo Patriciello, and Isabella Tovaglieri—calls for "greater margins of flexibility," given the Italian situation. "Italy presents profoundly different characteristics compared to other member states," the three MEPs emphasize, "having one of the oldest building stocks in Europe, a high diffusion of private real estate ownership and a significant number of historic buildings or buildings subject to urban planning and landscape restrictions”, It follows therefore – underline the three representatives of the Carroccio – that “a rigid and uniform application of the obligations set out in the directive risks leading to very significant economic costs”.
Ma Energy Commissioner Dan Jørgensen gives a response that leaves no room for manoeuvre."The directive," he recalls, "already provides considerable flexibility to take into account national specificities, particularly for Member States with a significant share of historic or protected buildings, like Italy." And in any case, he adds, for greater clarity, "national building renovation plans are an essential tool that allows Member States to transform their building stock into an energy-efficient and decarbonized resource by 2050."
Regarding costs, Dan Jørgensen points out: “The text does not impose renovation obligations on individual homes, but sets targets for reducing the energy consumption of the overall building stock. This allows Member States to define the most appropriate and cost-effective paths, prioritizing the most feasible interventions.
And in this regard, it should be added that Italy is still late in submitting the draft national building renovation plan, and for this very reason it was the subject of infringement proceedings initiated in March. Yet another. The data updated to the end of April of this year show the infringements against our country are at 75, of which 59 for violation of Union law and 16 for failure to transpose directives
